When you’ve lived through abuse, one of the hardest truths to face is this: yes, an abuser can control themselves. That statement alone can take years to fully accept, because so many of us were conditioned to believe their behaviour was caused by stress, anger, or circumstance. We were told, “They just snapped,” or “They didn’t mean it.” But deep down, you start to notice a pattern that exposes the truth—if they can control how they speak, act, and appear in front of others, they can also control themselves behind closed doors. What changes isn’t their ability—it’s their audience.
Abuse is not a loss of control. It’s the calculated use of it. Abusers are often deliberate, strategic, and painfully aware of when to turn on the charm and when to unleash cruelty. They can smile in public, offer compliments, and appear calm and collected when it benefits them. They know how to impress, gain sympathy, and make people believe they are kind, faithful, and respectable. Then, when the doors close and the witnesses are gone, they become someone else entirely. That shift isn’t an accident. It’s manipulation at its finest—maintaining power while keeping the victim silent and confused.
If an abuser were genuinely unable to control themselves, they would treat everyone the same way. But they don’t. They never yell at their boss, curse at the pastor, or shove a stranger in line at the grocery store. They know precisely when to restrain themselves. They’re fully capable of appearing calm when there are consequences at stake. That alone proves that their behaviour is a choice. What they “lose control” of is not their temper—it’s their mask, and only when they think it’s safe to do so.
This duality—the charming public persona versus the private cruelty—is one of the most confusing parts of abuse. The person everyone else sees is often kind, attentive, and generous. People speak highly of them, trust them, and defend them. Meanwhile, you’re living with a version no one else knows. You watch them praise others while criticizing you, raise their voice in rage one minute and then greet a friend sweetly the next. You begin to question your own perception. You think, “Maybe it really is me. Maybe I am too sensitive.” That confusion is part of their design. By maintaining a spotless public image, they create a shield of credibility for themselves and a cloak of doubt around you. If you ever speak up, they’ve already built a world that won’t believe you.
The truth is that abusers are experts at image management. They study people’s reactions, learn what earns trust, and tailor their behaviour accordingly. It’s why many of them seem “so nice” or “so godly” in public. They use charm as a form of control and faith language to manipulate. Some even quote Scripture or speak about forgiveness while ignoring repentance. But God is not mocked. His Word says that self-control is a fruit of the Spirit. If someone truly walks with Him, that fruit will be visible not only in church pews or social circles but in the hidden corners of home. You can tell a tree by its fruit; rotten fruit can’t be disguised forever.
What many call a “loss of control” is the deliberate use of anger as a weapon. Rage becomes a tool to dominate, to silence, to make you walk on eggshells. And when the storm passes, the abuser often acts as though nothing happened. They may even cry or say sorry to reset the power balance, not out of conviction. The goal isn’t reconciliation—it’s control. True repentance leads to change; manipulation leads to repetition. That’s the difference between a heart that wants healing and a person who wants to win.
The Bible warns about those who appear righteous outwardly but are full of hypocrisy and wickedness within. It’s a verse that hits differently when you’ve lived it. Abusers don’t just harm people—they distort truth itself. They make evil look good and good look evil. They convince you that silence is loyalty and endurance is love. But real love does not destroy. It doesn’t leave you trembling or apologizing for being in pain. Love is patient and kind. Love protects. Love rejoices with the truth. And that’s why truth is so threatening to an abuser—because truth unmasks what they’ve spent so much time trying to hide.
It’s heartbreaking how often victims are doubted because the abuser’s mask is so convincing. People see the public version—the friendly, composed one—and assume that’s who they really are. They can’t imagine that the same person who leads worship, coaches little league, or helps a neighbour shovel snow could be cruel in private. But that’s how abuse works. It thrives in darkness and relies on disbelief. The difference between how an abuser behaves in public and how they behave in private is one of the most evident proofs that their actions are intentional, not impulsive. They choose when to appear kind, be cruel, and play the victim themselves.
The truth may be painful, but it’s also freeing. When you finally understand that their behaviour wasn’t because of you, your shortcomings, or something you did wrong—it was because of their desire to control—you stop trying to fix what you never broke. You stop believing that if you just prayed harder, loved more, or forgave faster, they would change. You start seeing their words for what they are—excuses. And you start seeing yourself as God sees you—worthy of peace, safety, and love that doesn’t leave bruises on the heart.
So, can an abuser control themselves? Yes. They’ve been doing it all along. They control their temper when the police drive by. They control their tone when the pastor calls. They control their story when they need sympathy. The only time they “lose control” is when they think there will be no consequences. That’s not lack of control—that’s abuse.
If you’ve ever questioned your reality because they seemed so different around others, please know this: you’re not imagining it. You’re seeing the truth that others haven’t yet seen. And though they may deceive people for a time, nothing hidden stays hidden forever. The Bible says, “There is nothing concealed that will not be disclosed, or hidden that will not be made known.” God sees every mask, every manipulation, every secret act of cruelty done in the dark. One day, all of it will be brought into the light.
And when it is, remember this—it’s not your job to expose them; God promises to reveal the truth. Your job is to heal, to walk in freedom, and to trust that the same God who saw every moment of your pain will bring justice in His time. They controlled themselves when they wanted to; now you can take back the control they stole from you. Because truth, once seen, cannot be unseen—and it’s truth that sets you free.